Are you a Quiet Speculation member?
If not, now is a perfect time to join up! Our powerful tools, breaking-news analysis, and exclusive Discord channel will make sure you stay up to date and ahead of the curve.
Triple Theros was my first limited PTQ Top 8, and last weekend marked my third, with the second and third both being triple Khans. With a second place finish in the Theros PTQ, two Top 4 finishes with Khans and a Modern Top 8 in-between, you might say I'm hungry.
I don't believe that I'll have much of any opportunity with Khans limited to qualify for the Pro Tour, but there are tons of Standard PTQs and PTQQs on the horizon. While my ultimate goal is to win a PTQ of any format, Standard is the final frontier of even Top 8ing for me, and it's a focus of mine as a player at this point in time.
I played the Standard Super IQ this weekend at the Fantasy Flight Game Center--home of the most reasonable on-site french fries I've ever had at a Magic tournament as well as holder of a liquor license--and it went decently. 5-3 for 27th place in a field of ~140. I think the biggest obstacle to my success was that I was playing too close to a stock deck, which didn't give me as good of a chance at success as doing something unexpected.
This is what I registered:
Jeskai Wins
The Elspeths do some serious work in this deck. After your opponent spends time battling quick, must-answer threats like Mantis Rider and Goblin Rabblemaster, they will often find themselves completely out of gas against the format's most powerful six drop. While Elspeth fits more seamlessly into decks like Abzan with their "just play all the good spells" nature, she still plays well here for those games where you're just not reasonably able to burn your opponents out.
On that matter, though, it really felt throughout the course of the tournament that I was only ever able to burn out opponents when the game wasn't particularly close.
More often, I would find myself at the mercy of Siege Rhinos and clocks much faster than using all of my mana to do four damage to my opponent. It seems to me that I would give myself the best chance of winning by either eschewing some burn spells for cards better at playing a controlling game, or to play a lower curve that lends itself to winning more games with burn faster.
I believe that the burn elements of this clan are much more powerful relative to other options than the controlling elements.
Not for nothing, it also might just be time (or even past time) to dump any Elspeths you have with the Elspeth versus Kiora duel deck on the horizon.
When I first picked up Jeskai, I noted that Seeker of the Way was a complete turd. It was the only creature in the deck that wasn't a must-answer and was often a Grizzly Bears with minimal upside. I chose the route of cutting the card, though supplementing it with more efficient threats could be the best way to utilize the amazing burn available in this format. I don't know if there is another two-drop creature that I especially like for this strategy, but there's a certain Modern and Legacy all-star that has my attention.
It would definitely take some retooling of the manabase to make a one-drop appealing in this deck. In particular, I don't think this inclusion is possible without playing at least eight painlands and would likely warrant some number of Mana Confluence. Our goal is to be extremely fast with the ability to burn out the other fast decks, which Seaker of the Way and Jeskai Charm help regain the life lost to our manabase.
Additionally, we'll be able to demolish the other aggressive decks by playing what I believe may be the most underplayed card in Standard:
Maybe it's the excitement over gold cards. Maybe it's the fascination with midrange. Maybe it's because everything is just good and a lot of people don't give red much respect, but this card being generally unplayed strikes me as a huge opportunity.
Particularly, this makes combat with Monastery Swiftspear and Seaker of the Way so much better. Say the opponent has a Courser of Kruphix. They might be fine blocking either of your creatures to save some life and trade you one-for-one. With Searing Blood, however, you get to make that trade in addition to getting in for 3 damage.
This is a non-trivial factor when Jeskai Charm and Stoke the Flames are legal. Now imagine that your opponent is just playing creatures that Searing Blood kills outright.
I'll also leave you to ponder how Searing Blood matches up against these two Planeswalkers:
I like the idea of hoarding Searing Bloods on the cheap. The card is serviceable for Modern and Legacy, and it won't take much for it to start showing up in Standard. With over 80% of PTQQs being Standard, I would find it hard to believe that you won't be able to get at least $1 a piece from anybody looking for them the morning of a tournament, and I definitely see it maintaining that price for its eternal relevance.
Cards like Siege Rhino and Polukranos, World Eater are still problematic. We do have answers, though.
I've been a fan of Suspension Field, and depending on how the final decklist ends up looking, finding a way to make Chained to the Rocks work is within the realm of possibility. They're certainly annoying opposition, but they're far from unbeatable.
Being as red as I want to be for a Monastery Swiftspear/Searing Blood deck does, of course, come with a cost, and that is Flooded Strand and therefor Dig Through Time become a lot more difficult to utilize.
I like the idea of sideboarding Dig against more controlling decks and possibly maindecking one, but if this deck ends up being inferior to other Jeskai builds, the loss of Dig would most likely be where the blame falls.
Putting it all Together
Everything above in mind, this is a rough draft of the kind of deck I want to start battling with:
Jeskai Don't Know
The manabase is a pretty big question mark. That's a lot of painlands, and that Flooded Strand is arguably wrong. Notably, this deck is going to be generally very unhappy if it has both the Plains and the Island in play and draws another non-red land, so there is definitely a risk there. It's a work in progress, but this might be the start of something beautiful.
As for the sideboard, I'd stick with things like Erase, counterspells, and probably Magma Sprays. Dig Through Time or Treasure Cruise also probably belong there to fight things like Dimir control. I'm much more concerned with hammering out the manabase and getting the numbers more concrete for now.
Have any thoughts on the deck? Think it's more reasonable to just play Boros or monored if we want to cast Searing Blood? Have another idea on underplayed cards that could shake up Standard? Let me know in the comments!
Thanks for reading.
-Ryan Overturf
@RyanOverdrive on Twitter
I have done a lot of playing around with aggro variant of Jeskai but I haven’t found anything that feels really good. I feel like in this format I want to be coming out of the gates fast and punish all the decks that play 3 tap lands T1-3 but I’ve felt like I just fizzle out and end up losing to all the lifegain that is out there right now before I can close the game out.
If you are going to play 4 seeker/4 swiftspear I think there is some merit to investigating Gods Willing or Defiant Strike for extra gas t3-4. With a red slant I like Sarkhan in the board against the midrange decks as a closer.
Anecdotal or I’m playing it terribly wrong but I also get smashed by the U/W heroic that has invested MTGO recently. Seems like this is the best punishing aggro deck right now. The combination of pumps+ god’s willing make it impossible to clear their guys and they close out the game much faster in most race situations. I started playing around with Mardu aggro lists as a result but still haven’t found anything that really fits.
Overall I like the game plan, keep us updated as the list progresses.
UW Heroic seems like a good matchup with Searing Blood and a punch of other removal spells. Obviously they have things like God’s Willing but we get to board into more removals like Magma Spray and Glare of Heresy. The deck is definitely strong, but this deck seems well positioned against it.
As for God’s Willing in this deck, it seems okay but I’m not sold. What does it play better than in my list? I’m more concerned about my opponent having a Siege Rhino than a Bile Blight, so I’d rather use my flex slots for things like Suspension Field and Distortion Strike.
Played about 10 matches with this list + 2 defiant strike in place of suspension field (put in sideboard) last night and I agree it was pretty underwhelming. Should be noted that I play mostly MTGO. I did beat 3 different abzan, although it may have been a fluke. In all the matchups I was able to burn them out before they landed a 2nd rhino. Once they hit 4 mana they were still using their turns try to burn my creatures which I think was a mistake. What are you thoughts on the Abzan matchup? Get in early with guys and go face with your burn to finish them (while praying no multiple rhino/sorin/whip)?
Still think U/W heroic is a pretty terrible matchup as they can easily get their dudes too burn to remove with any of your burn but Jeskai charm has been great.
Suspension Field helps against Heroic aftter they’ve protected against a burn spell. It could be a bad matchup but I definitely think just doing things like putting more Glare of Heresy in the board can solve it.
I definitely agree that the Abzan Matchup should be played as aggressively as possible and that you need to capitalize on the deck’s efficiency and just go upstairs with your burn. Have you been playing with Disdainful Stroke in your board? I liked it in my initial list against Abzan and I don’t see how it would be a bad option in this list.